Cindy Dodge is shy, lonely and has dreamed of having men of her own to love ever since she was old enough to understand what a ménage relationship was. However, because she’s shy, she doesn’t think that will ever happen.
Shane, Grant, Jake, and Curtis Kenny moved to Slick Rock after winning the bid to build Safe Haven. As soon as they meet Cindy at the diner, they’re entranced. When she shows up at the shelter for victims of abuse, they’re excited, but that quickly changes when she refuses an invitation to dinner.
The Kenny men come to the rescue when Cindy is hurt while being robbed and then again when she has an accident and breaks her wrist. Keeping the four men at a distance soon becomes a thing of the past and she agrees to be their girlfriend.
Unexpected danger sees her in peril again and since no one knows she’s even missing it’s up to her to escape, but this time she isn’t sure she’s going to win.